It’s an issue that is picked up later in the afternoon by Stephen Mangan, the other presenter. We chat on camera and again I am asked, what with my submission of a landscape set in the urban streets of Birmingham, what I make of a place like this. This time I explain how I see so much of the world through the lens of my working class upbringing and I’m very aware of the history of country estates and houses like this and how my Dad won’t visit them because ‘they are all built on the backs and blood and sweat of the working class’, he interrupts. ‘Well….yes,’ I say, not sure if he’s taking the piss.
We were all really exhausted as we stepped off the stage and walked towards the cameras for a shot of us ending the session. It turned out to be four more shots as we all did this really badly, much to the director’s dismay but my amusement (we are all artists not actors after all…) ‘Just look at my red T shirt as you come towards us!’ he barked before ‘no, back again….jeezuz’ he muttered under his breath.
And then the names
were called out by Stephen Mangan as the Judges stood behind him- I’ve noticed
they never make eye contact with the artists at this point- ‘Rosemary Firth,
Renata Fernandez…’ and at this point after the calling out of the names of the first
two artists I had a terrible, sinking realization that I had not gotten into
the top 3 as I knew Dougie would certainly be in it. ‘and Dougie Adams…’. I
felt absolutely gutted, really surprised at how competitive I had felt in the
end. The judges applauded and walked past us with their commiserations but I
felt a bit numb. Kathleen Soriano said to me as she passed ‘Oh, I loved yours!’
and I thought to myself, ‘Yeah? Well why didn’t you bloody pick it then! (My
apologies for my lack of magnanimity at this point. I’m just trying to write
honestly about the experience). The three artists who hadn’t made it through
were told to wait in the field adjacent to the easels until the winner was
called. I felt really fed up, and to make it worse I was then asked to do one
more interview to camera to tell the viewers how I felt about losing….great.
Dougie won the heat, a worthy winner I thought. We then had to tidy up our pods and pack up our equipment as our paintings were taken away to be wrapped up somewhere else on site. There had been some art materials available- some nice oils, acrylics and charcoal which I was told I could have which was very generous. Looking around all the activity as the crew started to pack up to my surprise I noticed the judges walking away. After spending six exhausting hours painting, weeks preparing, and then not getting through to the top three, I was hoping they would come over and offer us bit of feedback or at least some advice for the future- I think we all deserved that, but no, they were off. That was it. I was left with my disappointment, and a sense of ‘well, what happened there then?’. I suddenly felt like a small cog in the big machine of the TV production. They had got what they needed. I’d made a painting for the TV show. I could go now.
After...
I’ve been absolutely
dreading watching the programme and have even had sleepless nights about it
wondering what the judges actually thought and said, but also how I will come
across. Yes, it would be fair to say I had lost a bit of perspective.
At the halfway point, when the Judges have a bit of a conflab Joan Bakewell had said ‘well Shaun seems to know what he’s doing’, a phrase I thought I might get printed on a T-Shirt with Joan Bakewell’s name under it. The episode itself was not the best. I thought all the interesting bits of watching the artists at work which I have liked about the show when I have watched it did not feature, and neither did I in the end despite all the interviews and filming. I thought that might be the case though as I hadn’t made the top 3. I thought the ‘narrative’ of the episode would be cut around the 3 top artists of the day. Within an hour of the show being on however, I had sold a painting from my website store and by the weekend had sold two more, including my submission piece. For the next few days and more I received loads of positive feedback through my social media accounts about my appearance and more importantly my painting from friends but also fellow artists from all over the country, many of them past contestants on the show, praising my work and wanting to know more about my painting practice. Although I’m aware that it can be creatively fatal to take much notice of criticism both good and bad and that it’s best to just get on with ‘the work’, all this positive feedback does really give my confidence a much needed boost. Other artist friends offered a more critical perspective ranging from wondering what I was doing on the programme anyway as It seemed nothing to do with what I do, that the judges were ‘so empty’ and ‘where do they get these people from?!’. One friend the way the ‘wild cards’ are treated is ‘demeaning’, and many thought my painting was the best by far, which was nice (let me put that that one in). One friend said the difference with my work and the others was that it was actually ALIVE! Another artist friend who I met in Cornwall a week after taking part gently reminded me, ‘It’s just a TV show…’
A TV show or not (I hear those words again…’can you say ‘competition, not show?’) the programme has seemingly created a ripple effect in the weeks that have followed with more and more people taking an interest in my work. The best and most tangible thing to come out of it however, is the contact I have made and the relationships I am beginning to form with other professional artists. In fact, later in the summer I’m returning to West Wycombe park with the artists I met at my episode and the others who featured there in episode 4 to stage a live (not online!) exhibition of our work from the competition and some of our other work at the National Trust house at the Park (I’m not sure what my Dad will say!). That’s a lovely and unexpected outcome. In the meantime, I’m learning a great deal, not least that I’m not as good as so many of the artists I’m in touch with, and it is pushing me on to try and make my own work much stronger, be more critical and ask myself more questions about the work I do make and put out there. I’m making a lot of work at the moment, but a great deal of it I’m rejecting, painting over things to and try again and be more willing to try something different.
Beckett’s famous quote: “Ever tried. Ever failed. No matter. Try again. Fail again. Fail better’’ seems to sum my experience up, as it does so much of anyone’s attempts to be creative and to try and do something worthwhile and fulfilling, which in the end my participation in the competition has proved to be.
******
Can I move on now…? I’m sorry this has ended up reading more like a short story. It’s been difficult to write as I’ve been very conscious whenever people have asked me since what it was like my thoughts always come back to the difficult end to the experience. Yes, maybe I did lose perspective, but painting is so important to me, and I still think the judges should have taken the time to speak us with us all after how much work we had done. As an artist we are always made to feel grateful for any opportunity, and I felt that this was no exception and have had this said to me about this opportunity too, but as artists our passion for what we do is also continually exploited. We have to exhibit for free, give up our time for free, often we have to pay to exhibit (!), appear in front of millions watching on Sky Arts for free and yet still be grateful. It will do our careers good etc. And we are, and sometimes it does and sometimes it doesn’t and on it goes…I’ve had so many experiences as an artist very similar to this over the years. I wanted this one to be a little different. I just wish that our skills, experience and passion for what we do was respected and treated a bit better sometimes.
















































